Education
Intelligibility, Acceptability, and Comprehensibility
In the field of language teaching and assessment, particularly in relation to second language acquisition and pronunciation, the concepts of intelligibility, acceptability, and comprehensibility are crucial.
- Intelligibility:
- Definition: The extent to which a listener understands a speaker’s intended message.
- Focus: On the recognition of words and utterances.
- Importance: Fundamental for basic communication.
- Comprehensibility:
- Definition: The ease with which a listener understands a speaker’s message.
- Focus: On the effort required to understand the speech.
- Importance: Affects the overall effectiveness of communication.
- Acceptability:
- Definition: The degree to which speech conforms to the listener’s expectations of what sounds “correct” or “native-like.”
- Focus: On social and cultural norms of language use.
- Importance: Influences social acceptance and perception of the speaker.
These concepts are interrelated but distinct:
- Speech can be intelligible but not easily comprehensible (requiring more effort to understand).
- Speech can be comprehensible but not considered acceptable in certain contexts.
- Acceptability often varies based on the listener’s background and the communication context.
In language teaching, there’s a growing emphasis on prioritizing intelligibility and comprehensibility over native-like acceptability, especially in global English contexts. This approach recognizes the diverse nature of English use worldwide and focuses on effective communication rather than adherence to a single “standard” accent.